The Best Hanukkah Surprise Is a Cookie With Candy Inside


Dreidel, dreidel, dreidel I made you out of… cookies! (That’s how the song goes, right?!) No matter, these surprise-inside treats are the perfect way to get your whole crew excited for the Festival of Lights. Make ’em together, then dig in post- latkes .

What you’ll need:

  • A batch of sugar-cookie dough
  • Light blue fondant
  • Blue-and-white striped paper straws
  • Small gold candies or sprinkles
  • Royal icing
  • Rectangle cookie cutter
  • Small circle cookie cutter
  • Light corn syrup
  • Piping tip and bag

1. Roll and cut your dough

Roll out dough to about 3 to 4 mm, then cut out 3 rectangles per dreidel. Use a knife to cut away two angled sections at the bottom of each rectangle, creating a triangular shape at one end.

Take one of your dreidel-shaped cookies and cut out a circle in the center, which is where your gold candy or sprinkles will go (more on that later). Bake cookies according to the recipe, and let cool.

2. Stack and fill ’em up

Take one of the full dreidel cookies (without the hole cut-out) and pipe royal icing around the perimeter.

Top with the cookie with the hole in the center, and lightly press down.

Pour your golden candy or sprinkles into the circle! (We used tiny golden nonpareils and gold dusted chocolate candy beans.)

3. Attach the handle

Before adding the last layer of cookie, cut down a paper straw to 2-3 inches and flatten one end.

Attach the flattened end to the top of your stacked cookies with icing.

Add more icing around the perimeter before pressing on the top cookie layer.

4. Add some fondant

Roll out light blue fondant and cut to the same size as your cookies. Attach it to your top cookie with light corn syrup, then let set for 20 minutes.

5. Decorate away

Finally, jazz up your dreidel cookie however you like. (We splattered on some gold flecks with a paint brush, and added a white bow.)

Become a member for exclusive access to endless creative inspiration.
Using fondant is easy with Beth's techniques! Learn how to color, roll and cut fondant and to marbleize colors for a gorgeous finish. Then turn cookies into an adorable monogrammed chalkboard using black fondant. Finally, learn how to create fondant frills and layer colors for fondant stamps.
One of our favorite things about winter is that it’s more than OK to eat extra cookies and drink hot cocoa with loads of whipped cream. These mug-hugging cookies sit perfectly on the edge of your hot drink, just waiting to be dunked. Cute enough to cheer up the grouchiest Grinch!
Felicity and Krystle
Are you Team Buttercream or Team Fondant ? If you're not sure, you may want to know a little more about the pros and cons of each type of icing. And what about royal icing, you may ask? We'll cover that, too.
Jessie Oleson Moore
Now Reading
The Best Hanukkah Surprise Is a Cookie With Candy Inside