The Year of the Christmas Sweaters


The idea came to me the way all great ideas do: at the eleventh hour. A few weeks before Christmas, I stumbled upon a vintage sweater pattern, and fell hard. It was an adorable bulky zippered sweater, with a figure skater on the back. I just had to make it for my figure-skating mother. But why stop there??? Down the rabbit hole I went, and soon I'd surfaced vintage sweater patterns for almost everyone on my list: from a super cool motorcycle sweater for my then boyfriend (now husband — take that, sweater curse!), to a sweet kitten for my niece, and more. So much more.

Knowing I was in over my head, I called that figure-skating mom of mine, who also happens to be an amazing knitter, and she talked some sense into me. But only a little. Together, we would knit ten sweaters...for next Christmas. We gave ourselves a year to plan, knit, design, and so forth. And so began our year of the sweaters.

Pattern prep

Though we already had a handful of patterns, the thrill of the hunt was strong, and so we began by researching vintage Mary Maxim style sweater patterns — Etsy, eBay, you name it, we searched it. Finding an obscure pattern that neither of us had seen before was intensely satisfying, and you can bet we spent waaaay more time shopping patterns than we actually needed to. But, hey. We were having FUN!

Knit, knit, knit some more

Eventually, we started knitting. I knocked out the motorcycle sweater pretty quickly (my boyfriend was traveling, it was winter in New York, I had a LOT of solo knitting time). And then, because I'm the worst, I packed up all the pieces and mailed them home to my mom, who wove in all my ends, and seamed the entire sweater, then put in the zipper. She did this for every sweater I knit. Did I mention I'm the worst?

Boredom strikes

As my mom tackled my horse sweater, I started her figure skating sweater. And then I got bored. Two sweaters in and I was sick of following the rules. I did what any sensible knitter would do, and spent hours in an Excel sheet, charting out an insane intarsia heron chart for my sister's sweater. And then I knit it, twice. Sometimes the colors just aren't right, you know? And because that was so much fun, I designed an X-men sweater, too.

Spring turned to summer turned to fall. My mom and I stayed in regular contact, but couldn't quite keep each other motivated enough to knit all the things. Our sweater production started to lag. That's when we turned to Etsy and eBay once more, but this time to shop vintage finished sweaters. Yeah, we cheated on a few. My dad's pheasant hunting sweater was swiftly purchased, as was the sweater for my Grandma. We also wasted more time just shopping vintage sweaters we didn't actually buy. We like to shop. I'm not ashamed.

The big reveal

So, did we pull it off? Almost. That X-men sweater was short a sleeve on the big day, but close enough! We took the group photo as strategically as possible to hide the work-in-progress. Was it worth it? A resounding yes. Sweater Christmas was the gift that kept on giving. Sure, not all the sweaters became beloved wardrobe staples, but for an entire year, my mom and I had an excuse to talk knitting multiple times a week. It was glorious. And, we scored my most favorite family photo ever, shown above. Straight out of a horror movie, right?

Where are they now?

My mom and I both still have and wear our sweaters, and the horse sweater is proudly on display in my craft room. But not all sweaters have been so fortunate...

The Heron Sweater

You guys, I felted it. On accident. I thought I was doing my sister a favor by washing it for her, but instead I shrunk it. It's now niece-sized, and thus lives with my niece.

The Motorcycle Sweater

While the curse of the boyfriend sweater didn't strike, my now-husband NEVER wore this sweater. I regifted to an appreciative friend and this sweater is now living its best life.

The Ski Slope Sweater

This sweater, knit for my little sister's then boyfriend (who sadly, missed the group photo), was the sleeper hit of the sweaters. Kevin, bless him, wears his sweater often. Even better, he wears it on ski trips. Thank goodness they got married, so it's not weird that I still knit things for him...

close up of woman's hands knitting green and white yarn
Are you sure to want to remove this?
For makers, there is a certain impulse at holiday time — the sudden mania to MAKE ALL THE GIFTS. You’re crafty, you should lovingly DIY all your presents, right? Right?? We anxiously ask ourselves as we stand looking at our stashes. I have all this yarn…so much fabric...
handmade quilt folded with wrapped present on top
Are you sure to want to remove this?
If you're a maker, chances are visions of handmade gifts are already dancing in your head. And while "it's the thought that counts" is certainly a nice idea, the reality is that gifting handmade items takes work — so you really want your present to hit the bullseye. Here's how to set yourself up for success.
Jessie Oleson Moore
Are they KNIT-WORTHY? 10 Questions to Ask + Knitting Gift Ideas
Are you sure to want to remove this?
They say you should share your gifts with the world, but before you pick up those needles, you need to ask yourself a few questions. This week, learn Tracie and Jodi's method for determining someone's knitworthiness.
Now Reading
The Year of the Christmas Sweaters